Last updated on May 13th, 2023
Easy homemade plum jelly is a great introduction to making homemade jelly. This simple recipe has only a few ingredients and is big on flavor.
This post may contain affiliate links. Click here to learn more about how affiliate links are used on this site.
Until a year ago, my family was 100% team Mama’s Homemade Strawberry Jam. I bought a flat of Louisiana strawberries every spring from the farmer’s market, canned several batches of homemade jam and prayed that it would last us through until next spring.
That is, until one day last September. I was making a recipe that called for plum jelly. It was one of those situations where I only needed a couple of tablespoons, but I had to buy an entire jar. I didn’t want to let a perfectly good jar of jelly go to waste, so the next time I reached the bottom of a jar of homemade jam, I substituted the store bought plum jelly instead. Big mistake.
The moment that store bought jelly hit Big Brother’s lips, he decided it was the end all be all and never would he let another flavor of jelly touch his peanut butter sandwich. My child, who was raised on homemade, chose store bought. Traitor.
For the last 12 months, I’ve been shelling out $3 a pop for a jar of store bought plum jelly and it’s been killing me. Finally, a few weeks ago I spied a display of plums as I walked into the produce section of my store. Finally, victory would be mine again!
What’s the difference between jam, jelly and preserves?
You may have perused the jelly aisle and notice jars labeled jam, jelly, preserves or marmalade. They are all produced the same way. The difference is in how the fruit is treated.
- Jelly is made with fruit juice only.
- Jam is make with pureed or crushed fruit.
- Preserves have large chunks of fruit in them.
- Marmalade is made with the peels only and made exclusively with citrus fruits.
How to extract the juice from plums
Don’t worry, you won’t be standing over a juicer for hours. We extract the juice by cooking the plums down. You’ll need about five pounds of plums for 8 (8 oz.) jelly jars. Start by cutting open your plums and removing the pits.
I don’t bother peeling them because we will be straining our liquid anyway. Word to the wise, wear and old t-shirt for this part. Depending on how juicy your plums are, this can get messy and the juice stains.
Place your pitted plums in a large stock pot. Cover them with 1 ½ cups of water. Bring the pot to a boil, then reduce the heat to low, cover the pot and simmer for 10 minutes.
Next, we want to separate the juice from the cooked fruit. I used a dollar store fine mesh colander I had on hand fitted over a mixing bowl. You can also use a fine mesh strainer or line a colander with several layers of cheese cloth. I left the plums to sit for several hours to give the juice plenty of time to drain.
By this time, the fruit has drained and the juice has cooled (The color reminds me of a formal dress I wore in high school. Pretty, isn’t it?). You should have about 5 ½ cups of juice. Pour the juice back into a stock pot and add one package of pectin.
Wait, what’s pectin?
Pectin is a naturally occurring fiber found in fruits. It helps to thicken the jelly to a spreadable consistency. Some fruits have more pectin than others.
There are recipes out there for no-pectin jams and jellies. I haven’t had the best luck with them. I’d rather put the time in to make jelly only to end up with syrup. If you are worried about sugar, there are some low sugar pectins out there that I have had great success with.
Why Do You Add Butter to Homemade Jam?
We’re also going to one tablespoon of butter to the pot. As your juice boils, it will start to foam. The foam is just air bubbles and it won’t hurt you to eat it. But it can cause your jelly to look cloudy. If you are planning on canning your jelly, it can also affect the shelf life. The butter breaks the surface tension and prevents the foam from forming in the first place.
However, if you forget the butter, don’t sweat it. You’ll just need to skim the foam off the top before pouring the jelly into jars.
How to Make Plum Jelly
Once you’ve added the pectin and butter, bring the juice to a full rolling boil over high heat. That just means that the boil doesn’t stop when you stir it. Keep boiling and add the sugar. Boil for one minute. Boiling it for longer will cause the jelly to become more firm and harder to spread. Skim off any foam that has formed with a metal spoon. Discard the foam.
The jelly will be syrupy at first. It will thicken as it cools. But if you’re just dying to know if the jelly set or not, there is a way to test it. Stick a meta spoon in the freezer for several minutes. Once it’s good a cold, lay it on the counter and dribble a few drops of the jelly on it. The jelly on the spoon should set within a matter of minutes.
How to Store Homemade Plum Jelly
Jelly has a longer shelf life than other types of jams or preserves because of its higher sugar content. Jelly what has not been canned will last one year in the fridge.
I prefer to can my homemade jams and jellies. Because of its high acid content, plum jelly can be processed using the water bath canning method. Check out my beginner’s guide to waterbath canning.
Simply fill clean jars, leaving ¼-inch of headspace. Fill the pot until the jars are covered with at least one-inch of water. Bring the water to a boil, then cover the pot and process for ten minutes. Remove the pan from the heat.
Give the jars 24 hours to cool. Then check the seal by pressing the center of the lid. If it doesn’t give, your jars are sealed!
I’m happy to report, no more store bought jelly for Big Brother’s peanut butter sandwich. He’s seen the error of his ways and I have forgiven him. All is right in the universe.
You Might Also Enjoy:
- Beginner’s Guide to Water Bath Canning
- How to Make Homemade Strawberry Jam
- Pepper Jelly
- Vanilla Bean Honeysuckle Jelly
Homemade Plum Jelly
- 5 pounds fully ripe plums
- 1-1/2 cups water
- 1 (1.75 ounce) box fruit pectin
- 1 tablespoon unsalted butter
- 6-1/2 cups granulated sugar
- Slice the plums in half and remove and discard the pits. Don’t bother peeling them.
- Place the plums in a large stockpot. Add the water. Bring the pot to a boil, then cover and simmer over medium heat for 10 minutes.
- Strain the juice by pouring through a fine mesh strainer or line a colander with several layers of cheesecloth. Allow the fruit to drain for about 30 minutes. Discard the fruit.
- You should have about 5 ½ cups of plum juice. Pour the juice back into the pot. Add one box of pectin and the butter. Bring the juice to a hard rolling boil.
- Add the sugar. Continue to boil the jelly for one minute. Remove the pot from the heat. Skim any foam from the top with a metal spoon.
- Ladle the jelly into clean jars. Jelly can be stored for one year in the fridge.
- Jelly can also be canned using the water bath canning method. Leave ¼ – inch of headspace in each jar. Top with lids and bands. Process for 10 minutes. Unopened jars can be stored in a cool, dry place for up to 2 years.
Hi, Judy. Jelly does not have fruit pieces in it. It’s only made from the juice. My son prefers the jelly, so that’s what I made. If you are looking for something with fruit in it, I would recommend searching for plum jam or plum preserves.
Why do u not use the fruit in the jelly? I love fruit I my jelly.
Question is how do I incorporate fruit into this jelly recipe?
Hi, Gail! I removed the pits to cut down on cooking time. You can leave them in because, as you said, you’re just using the juice. But your cook time will likely differ from mine. The leftover fruit is completely edible. You could add it to yogurt or ice cream. If you garden, you can even add it to a compost bin.
For jelly, does it make a difference if the pits are left in since only the juice is used? And is there a good use for the left over pulp you can suggest?
Hi Geneva, how long have you given it to cool? It could take up to 48 hours, especially if you live in a hot and humid climate, for the jelly to completely set. It could also be a problem with the pectin. If it still does not gell up, measure out the jelly and pour it into a saucepan. If you have more than eight cups, you’ll need to work in batches. Bring the jelly to a boil, then for every four cups of jelly stir in 1/4 cup of white sugar and one tablespoon of powdered pectin. Bring the jam to a boil, then cook for 5-10 minutes, stirring constantly. Test for gelling using the frozen spoon method I describe above.
I followed the plum recipe to a T and it’s cooled and still runny. I put a jar in refrigerator and it je
Gelled up but when I took it back out it went runny again. What am I doing wrong?
Hi Sybil, yes it will continue to thicken as it cools. You need to give it at least 24-48 hours. If it is still runny, measure out the jam, then pour it into a saucepan. If you have more than eight cups, you’ll need to work in batches. Bring the jam to a boil, then for every four cups of jam stir in 1/4 cup of white sugar and one tablespoon powdered pectin. Bring the jam to a boil, then cook for 5-10 minutes, stirring constantly. Test for gelling using the frozen spoon method I describe above.
I just finished the hot bath. Jar lids popped but it is still runny. Will it hell when cool? If not is there a way to salvage it?
Hi Darlene! I have never measured the temp when I make this. Roiling boil for one minute has always worked for me.
You say to boil plum jelly for a minute after it comes to rolling boil. Are you saying you don’t need to reach 220 degrees F ?